Investors trust mutual funds to manage their hard-earned money efficiently and ethically. However, certain unethical practices, like front-running, have shaken investor confidence in the past. From HDFC Mutual Fund to Axis and most recently, Quant Mutual Fund, front-running scams have raised concerns about how fund houses operate. While SEBI has been actively cracking down on such cases, it is essential for investors to stay vigilant. But what exactly is front-running, and how can you identify red flags before it’s too late? Let’s dive deeper.
Investors can also read 20 Equity Funds with Low Beta and High Alpha
What is a Front-Running Scam in Mutual Funds?
Front-running is an illegal practice where fund managers or dealers trade securities in their personal accounts before executing large trades on behalf of the mutual fund. Since large fund orders impact stock prices, front-runners take advantage of the price movement to make personal gains at the expense of investors.
For example, if a fund manager knows that a mutual fund will purchase a large quantity of a stock, they might buy it first in their personal account. Once the fund’s bulk order goes through, the stock price rises, allowing them to sell at a profit. This unethical practice distorts fair market pricing and undermines investor trust.
Historical Front-Running Scams in Mutual Funds in India
Several mutual fund houses have faced front-running allegations in recent years. Here are some major cases:
- HDFC Mutual Fund (2020)
In July 2020, SEBI penalized entities associated with HDFC AMC for engaging in front-running. Certain dealers used insider information to trade stocks ahead of official fund transactions. - Axis Mutual Fund (2022)
One of the most high-profile cases in recent times, Axis Mutual Fund terminated its chief dealer Viresh Joshi and fund manager Deepak Agrawal for alleged front-running. SEBI and the Enforcement Directorate conducted searches, leading to a deeper investigation into illicit trading practices. Before the scam broke out, Axis Mutual Fund’s schemes were significantly outperforming their peers, which later turned into underperformance after the front-running activities were exposed. We have reiterated this in our article Axis Mutual Funds are worst performers during 2022. - Quant Mutual Fund (2024)
The latest case under SEBI’s radar, Quant Mutual Fund, faced allegations of front-running in June 2024. SEBI raided its offices in Mumbai and Hyderabad, investigating irregular trading activities by insiders. Before the scam came to light, many Quant MF schemes were delivering unusually high returns compared to peers. However, after the regulatory scrutiny, these funds started underperforming, indicating potential mismanagement of trades.
How to Spot Early Warning Signs of Front-Running in Mutual Funds?
While investors do not have direct access to internal fund transactions, certain red flags can indicate unethical practices. Here’s what you should look for:
- Unusual Stock Movements Before Fund Announcements
If a stock shows an abnormal price surge or drop before a mutual fund discloses its buy/sell transactions, it could indicate front-running. - Frequent Changes in Fund Managers or Dealers
If a mutual fund frequently changes its fund managers or chief dealers without a clear reason, it might signal internal governance issues. - Sudden Performance Spikes or Drops in a Scheme
If a mutual fund scheme suddenly outperforms or underperforms without a justified market reason, it could be due to internal manipulations. For instance, Axis Mutual Fund schemes were delivering excessive returns before the scam surfaced, followed by significant underperformance afterward. Similarly, Quant Mutual Fund schemes showed extraordinary gains before coming under SEBI’s scrutiny, and their performance has since deteriorated. - Regulatory Investigations & Whistleblower Reports
Keep an eye on SEBI reports, media articles, and whistleblower claims about fund houses. Even initial investigations can be a sign of potential issues. - Excessive Portfolio Churning
A high turnover ratio in a mutual fund’s portfolio could indicate excessive trading, possibly linked to front-running.
You can also check Bullet Proof Ways to Protect your MF portfolio from Scams.
Tips to Protect Your Mutual Fund Investments
As an investor, you can take proactive steps to safeguard your portfolio from funds involved in unethical practices:
- Stick to Reputed Fund Houses
While any AMC can have issues, sticking to well-regulated, transparent fund houses with a clean track record reduces risks. - Review Portfolio Changes Regularly
Keep an eye on the fund’s portfolio disclosures. If a fund frequently buys and sells the same stocks, investigate further. - Follow SEBI & AMFI Guidelines
SEBI regularly updates regulations to curb fraudulent activities. Being aware of regulatory changes helps investors stay informed. - Monitor Fund Manager Track Record
Check the past history of fund managers before investing. If a manager was involved in controversies before, be cautious. - Diversify Your Investments
Spreading investments across multiple fund houses minimizes the impact of any single fund’s unethical practices. Investing in Diversified Mutual Fund Portfolio across AMCs can help to reduce the risk here.
Conclusion: Front-running scams in mutual funds have caused significant concerns for investors. While SEBI continues to tighten regulations, investors must remain vigilant and informed. By watching out for early warning signs and following best practices, you can protect your hard-earned money from unethical fund houses.
Have you ever suspected any irregularities in mutual funds you invested in? Share your thoughts in the comments below!
Discover more from Myinvestmentideas.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.