Gold Mutual Funds and Gold ETF’s – Which is the better investment option?
Gold Mutual funds and Gold ETF’s – Which is the better investment option?
This article is based on topic suggested by a reader through "suggest a topic".
One of the best investment options for long term, is investment in Gold. Thought there are various ways to invest in gold, investors are looking to invest in gold mutual funds and gold ETF’s. Which one is better investment option in case one is looking for investment in gold?
Why to invest in gold?
As indicated in several articles earlier, investment in gold has provided excellent returns of 22%+ p.a. over the last few years and which is safest and best investment option. Investors are looking to make this part of their investment portfolio.
What are gold ETF’s?
Gold ETF’s are exchange traded funds which invest in gold. The Gold ETF unit denotes 1 gram of gold. At current rate of gold, a gold ETF would value at Rs 3,100 per unit (less any administration expense). Gold ETF’s company purchases the gold and they would be stored. The Gold ETF’s then issue various denominations and they are traded in stock exchanges like any other stock.
What are gold mutual funds?
Gold mutual fund mainly invests in securities that are isused by the companies who invest in mining and distribution of gold. The NAV of the unit is determined like any other mutual fund. However gold mutual funds are relatively new products issued more than an year ago.
Gold mutual funds Vs Gold ETF’s – which is better investment option?
Investment: Gold ETF’s purchase gold from international market, hence the price of the gold ETF’s are transparent and they are listed in the stock exchanges through the day during trading hours. On the other hand, Gold mutual funds invest in securities of companies which are in mining and exploration of gold, hence there can be slight variance in the gold prices. Investment in Gold ETF’s are like direct investment in gold, whereas investment in gold mutual funds are indirect investment in gold through investment in equity of the companies.
Benefitting from Systematic Investment Plan: Investment in gold mutual funds can be done through Systematic Investment Plan. With this option the rupee cost averaging can be done. However such benefit is not available in gold ETF to invest a fixed amount of money every month.
Demat account: Investment in Gold ETF require a demat account to be opened. Investment in Gold mutual funds is like any other mutual funds where you do not require a demat account
Liquidity: In case there is increase of Gold prices, Gold ETF prices increase and you can sell them in stock exchanges with the transaction charges. However in Gold mutual funds, if you want to sell the fund units, the NAV of previous day is taken as basis wherein you cannot en-cash the price fluctuations for the day.
Charges: If you invest in Gold ETF’s you need to pay the brokerage/transaction charge and demat account annual charges. If you are already doing share trading, you need not pay any additional demat charges and it may not impact you. If you invest in Gold ETF’s for longer term, the transaction charges would be minor and can be ignored. On the other hand, investment in gold mutual funds also attract transaction charges. On top of it, it attracts 1% exit load if you are exiting within 1 year. If you invest in gold mutual funds for longer term, you would get benefited.
Administrative expenses: In gold ETF’s, there is direct investment in gold, hence no additional expensese would be required for research or maintenance of big team by the mutual fund company. Hence the administrative expenses would be low and are generally around 1% of the total investment amount which the asset management company would reduce from the NAV of the mutual fund. On the other hand Gold mutual funds need to do research and invest in companies who are in mining and exploration of gold, hence the expenses would be on the higher side. Generally such expenses are around 1.5% of the investment amount.
Some of the Gold ETF’s in India
Some of the gold mutual funds in India
Conclusion: Investment in gold mutual funds and gold ETF’s have their pros and cons. Take a decision based on what suits you better and invest in them. In my opinion, since gold mutual fund are relatively new (which started an year back), and if you look at the performance, gold ETF's have been performing well considering one year performance period. I want to invest for 1 gram and in multiple of 1 gram of gold every month. In such situtaion, I would rank Gold ETF as better one rathern than gold mutual fund.
If you enjoyed this article, share the link in Facebook/Twitter. The links are provided below.
Gold Mutual funds and Gold ETF’s – Which is the better investment option?
- Avalon Technologies IPO Review – Should you Invest? - March 29, 2023
- ICICI Prudential Innovation Fund NFO – Issue Details and Review - March 26, 2023
- New Debt Mutual Funds Taxation Rules from 1-Apr-2023 - March 24, 2023
Thanks & regards…
I have one query.If a select fixed amount(say 3000/) for SIP in SBI gold etf & the price becomes say 3200/ then would i get (3000/3200)= .9375 units/grams or no purchase will be done??? What do u suggest- 1. should i select a fixed amount for a fixed date of a month
2. or I should invest manually every month but in this case I have to keep a track upon the gold price every day???
No Priyajit, You need to specify amount of quantity in SEP e.g. You can specify Rs 7,000 as SEP amount. If gold price is Rs 3,000, it would execute only 2 units. If it is Rs 3,500, it would still execute 2 units only. But if the amount is Rs 4,000, it would execute only 1 unit as with RS 7,000 we can buy only 1 unit of gold. The amount executed would be Rs 4,000 only. Now coming to second option, you can specify Qty. Means, you can say 2 units. If the rate is Rs 2,800 or Rs 3,000 or Rs 3,500 it is immaterial, it would buy 2 units every month
It was really an eye-opener for me. I was looking for investment in Gold ETFs. My query : Is it possible for me to go for SIP(say, Rs, 2000 per month) to invest in Gold ETFs? yes, I have a demat a/c with a renowned broker. Pl help how can I invest in Gold ETF through SIP.
Hi Somit, Investment in Gold ETF’s needs to be done like investment in stocks. You need to have a demat account. However, you can opt for SIP/SEP in Gold ETF’s. You can buy either fixed number of units (say 1gm, 2 gms, 3 gms etc.,) or invest upto a fixed amount (e.g. upto Rs 6,000 would give you 2 units/grams of gold. If gold rate is increasing say Rs 3,100 per gram, you would get only 1 unit/gram of gold as your amount of Rs 6,000 would not be sufficient to buy 2 units/grams of gold). BTW, how is our blog and do you have any recommendations ? If you liked this article, why don’t you share this on your facebook so that you can friends would also get benefitted ?
I agree Gold ETF is a better way of investing compared to Gold MF. Moreover investment in Gold has emerged as one of the best way to create wealth sicne the last 10-15 years.
thanks for this comparision.
I am interested in investing in SBI Gold ETF.
Could you please suggest a good brokerage where I can open a Demat account?
Thanks in advance!
Santosh, pls read this article, you can choose a good broker for demat account. https://myinvestmentideas.com/2013/02/how-to-choose-a-good-broker-for-demat-account-services/